Experiments have uncovered that classical music, especially Mozart’s pieces, improves health conditions of humans and other animals.
However, there is one girl in my class who absolutely despises classical music, and I’m wondering why her mind doesn’t feel “soothed” when she listens to it.
I always thought classical music has a relaxing effect on people, but what’s with the “I HATE classical music!” from that girl?
I know everybody has their own tastes, but classical music is a genre that NATURE accepts. So why not all humans?
Powered by Yahoo Answers
« previous post
How does the key signature effect t...
Joseph G Why is it that a song with no/little sharps or flats sounds better when it is transposed to a key signature with many sharps or flats? I have heard that Mozart wrote a book on this subject. But surely a melody in C major sounds the same when played in F sharp major as all intervals remain t...
next post »
Music teacher switching to literacy....
Jazzfanatic What master's degree would best suit me? I'm a music teacher, but I want to become a reading (English, not music) specialist. I want to use music activities to help kids who struggle with reading - ala Mozart Effect/multiple intelligences/etc. I have found courses that offer certifica...
14 Responses to “Classical music is supposed to have a positive effect on plants and animals, but why do some humans hate it?”
No trackbacks yet.
Posts with similar tags
No post with similar tags yet.
Posts in similar categories
- Classical Music
Fadi Ayat Classical Music“Classic Music” is a term used to refer to a wide range of music that is produced in or rooted in the traditions of Western art, ecclesiastical and concert music. It has been spanning the ages from the 9th century to the present time. Classical music is still played by many of... - Classical Music: not Just for Oaps
Adam Singleton For too long, classical music has been regarded as the domain of instrumentalists, composers, academic musicologists and, typically, anyone over 40 years old. But while the majority of today's youth would rather listen to Britney Spears' greatest hits or watch My Chemical Romance on MTV, the view that young people are completely uninterested... - Listening to mozart when your pregnant can make your baby smart?
Ashley h I heard that letting your baby listen to mozart while your pregnant can make him smart. Does anyone know the actual effects of letting your baby listen to mozart? im just wondering if its true based on facts.Powered by Yahoo Answers
... - Contemporary Or Classical Musical Instruments?
Lanny Hintz Playing a musical instrument is a gift to all those who hear it. Does it really matter if you play a classical musical instrument or a contemporary musical instrument? It can. First and foremost, playing a musical instrument should be fun and rewarding. If it's not, you are not likely to practice it... - What effect does classical music have on the nervous system?
Rebecca Jordan I am doing a science project on this topic - and whatever info or answers I get, help!! (So basically I'm just wondering what you think the effect of classical music is on the nervous system or what you do know about this. REMEMBER, your opinion helps...a lot!! -Thanks!Powered by Yahoo Answers
... - how do you feel when you listen to baroque and jazz music?
StHoly just want to get to know the opinions from people who listen to baroque and jazz music. some find baroque music soothing and relaxing and some find jazz is fun and cheerful, so what do you think? and how do you feel?
thank you
eg for baroque composers - js bach, george frederich handelPowered by Yahoo... - The Importance Of Drums in Classical Music
Malcolm Blake The warp and woof of music are rhythm and melody, and the drums are the rhythm instruments par excellence. It is easier to recognize a song by its rhythm without melody than it is by its melody without rhythm, which shows what a basic part of music is rhythm.Primitive music is more rhythm... - Michael Perlowin Presents Unique-sounding Classical Music Inspired by Spain
Eric de Fontenay Michael Perlowin breaks new ground with innovative and enjoyable music performed primarily and surprisingly on the pedal steel guitar.As with his forays into the world of Debussy, Stravinsky and Broadway with his Firebird Suite and West Side Story albums, Michael Perlowin is again shattering the stereotype of the pedal steel guitar as... - Classical Music?
Lollie I want to download some classical music to help me relax and wined down especially when I am studying. But I want a free site with free downloads and you don't have to sign up or enter any details. Is there such a place???Powered by Yahoo Answers
... - Is classical music relevant to the rock music we listen to today?
hayley I want to apply for the Arts Concentration program at my school for music, which puts a lot of emphasis on the classical genre.
I was just wondering, how relevant is classical music to rock, alternative, hard rock, and metal? I know the rules of music should apply to all genres, but will I...
Redeemer
March 13, 2009 - 11:36 amPowered by Yahoo Answers
Because they’re idiots. I say forget them. My brothers are the same way. They can’t accept music that doesn’t have words. It feels unnatural to them.
For me, classical music is the purest of music. The fact that there’s no “lyrics” makes them instantly timeless, and will live on for the next thousand years unlike today’s mainstream music, which typically is forgotten within years. Classical music transcends language barriers, and everyone can enjoy it. It will live on, especially through film music.
Arundhati Bakshi
March 13, 2009 - 6:10 pmPowered by Yahoo Answers
Its probably partly from ignorance. Hating “Classical Music” is like hating “Asian Music” . . . the term is so broad it has virtually no meaning. Wagner is as different from Mozart as Motorhead is from Barbara Streisand, and chances are very good that she already knows a good bit of classical music that she likes, since it surrounds us all the time. Possibly she associates it with a certain mindset or something like that. However, you know when you listen to the Harry Potter theme or watch Star Wars, that’s pretty much classical music. Also a lot of classical music can be more demanding that pop tunes. Schoenberg will require as much effort as Thelonius Monk to “get” and may take some concentrated listening instead of the more visceral reactions you usually associate with hip hop or metal music.
t r
March 14, 2009 - 12:54 pmPowered by Yahoo Answers
to start sounding new age. all music can be simply described as energy, transmitted through the vibrating air, just like every other sound. the theory behind why some sounds are soothing, some give you energy (make you want to move) others put you to sleep, and others make you cringe, (if I only had a black board I would drag my fingernails across for effect) is that the “energy” comes in conflict, amplifies, or alters your own body energy.
this girl is probably so used to city life that her body rejects nature. (take her camping and see if you don’t end up with a b!t(h in the tent) but I would bet that she loves a dance club.
fredrick z
March 16, 2009 - 8:05 pmPowered by Yahoo Answers
What you are talking about may be the so called “Mozart effect.” Some studies suggest that listening to Mozart prepares the brain to think spatially.
Children disliking classical music is normal. They are attempting to rebel and perhaps see classical music as a symbol of the stogy past.
Unfortunately they are usually so limited in life experiences that the music they choose to express their disdain of tradition is the most traditional, simplest music available.
As people mature more and more of them come to appreciate classical music. And interestingly, it is never the other way around where maturity breeds appreciation of what ever the pop music of the moment might be.
Michael H
March 18, 2009 - 5:13 pmPowered by Yahoo Answers
Perhaps the postive effect on plants is because they are trying to grow legs so they can run away ?
CM is sort of ok in small doses. Personally, i’m always waiting for the guitar solo that never comes.
toutvas bien
March 19, 2009 - 12:31 amPowered by Yahoo Answers
Classical requires actual thought some people don’t like being made to think is one way to see it …. another way is that what you are playing is just not exciting to her ….
now the rant portion Mozart is boring to many people (I LOVE MOZART) because it is and can be soothing and it is very structured .. his music is more intellectual than emotional try something like Rite of Spring or some Prokofiev … something emotional, wild and a bit savage … something more rhythmic
Mozart isn’t right for everyone. Damn the studies I didn’t really care for Mozart until I grew up.
Nutbushcitylimits
March 20, 2009 - 9:11 amPowered by Yahoo Answers
Some people do not take classical music into account these people are usually the ignorant ones who prefer to listen to R & B, I listen 2 all viretys of music apart from R & B and re_run Techno crap, I like rock but love classical, this is why when listening to classical to wind down i listen to “vanessa mae” because theres a mixture of both rock and classical mixed together. but i think classical is good becasue the difference and complexity of each note like “beetoven’s 9th symphony”
Steve S
March 23, 2009 - 4:48 amPowered by Yahoo Answers
People who hate Classical music also hate pretty much anything that requires thought and patience. We now live in a world where people are into ‘instant gratification’. If something isn’t constantly stimulating them, you get the old “I’m bored!” response. This is not uncommon in younger folks, so I am not surprised or upset by this response. But, when you find adults who act this way, I suspect there are some issues. Arrested development, ADD, substance abuse or just downright ignorance are the usual suspects.
Evan M
March 25, 2009 - 6:43 amPowered by Yahoo Answers
It’s probably because they haven’t heard the kind of classical music they can enjoy up til now. In my case I used to hate reading fiction books b/c 99% of what I was forced fed in school was drivel (can we please stop reading Lord of the Flies?). Getting a reading list from school is like taking fashion tips from your grandmother. Being told you are wrong for not enjoying something that someone supposedly “higher up” than you will make you all the more resentful of that which they are trying to push.
Unlike pop/rock/rap, classical music isn’t exactly all around us and for most people it would take effort to find the variety they like, something most people are not willing to do if they are satisfied with popular music.
I used to not much care for (but didn’t hate) classical music b/c to me much of it seemed long and pointless, like elevator music. I tend to enjoy more melodic pieces like Pachebel’s Canon, Saint Saens’ Dance of the Dead, Peter and the Wolf, Bach, George Gershwin, and Khachaturian.
boojumuk
March 27, 2009 - 5:03 amPowered by Yahoo Answers
Some people are just so common darling.
Chelsea
March 29, 2009 - 8:16 pmPowered by Yahoo Answers
Well I think it’s pretty obvious that girl is an ignorant bigot, who needs some sense knocked into her. I’d be more than happy to do the job.
Well anyway, I think classical music is the best music of all. In fact, it’s the only music I like. I hate all that pop crap out there. And I do admit, I used to like that “pop crap”, but ever since I saw the Movie Amadeus, I fell in love with classical music, and realized the stuff I was listening to was complete….eh, you get my point. [=
I mean come on, I don’t really get why people want to listen to singers, rappers, etc, repeating the same words over again, for 3 minutes. Teenagers (and I am a teenager myself), just don’t understand the beauty and mystery of classical music. My hope is for it to one day become mainstream again, but it’ll take forever to get all these ignorant people who hate it, to like it. So many people now a days just want to listen to something catchy, that they can sing along with. Who cares if they lose a couple of brain cells in the process? Ugh. I mean, I respect people who like pop, rock, etc. But if those people tell me that the only reason they don’t like classical music is because it’s boring and stupid, then it pisses me off. And then i’ll lose my respect for them.
I am so glad I discovered classical music. It changed my perspective of the world. That’s how powerful it is to me.
*sigh* well, that’s enough ranting for today, haha. (:
Kevin M
April 1, 2009 - 10:31 amPowered by Yahoo Answers
Let me start by saying that I am a professional classical musician I am a performer and a teacher of classical music. That said let me say some things that will likely be unpopular here, but are true.
Experiments have proven that plants grow better and more rapidly when ANY music is played for them, heavy metal or classical. The style made no difference.
Experiments on humans have not produced in strong scientific results. The results of the “Mozart Effect” tests have never been duplicated. In order for something to be proven scientifically the results must be able to be duplicated.
In my experience teaching people classical music, most dislike or hate comes from lack of knowledge about and exposure to classical music. If approached with the correct attitude and with the correct music, most students will develop some appreciation (if not like) of it.
There is also something off-puting about classical music to “outsiders” to the genre. Classical musicians and consumers of classical music have created a great deal of elitism around it. This can drive people to not bother to try to listen to or like the music. Classical music was not originally written for only an elite few, it was created for the masses, especially the music of the late Classical and Romantic Periods. This was music composed to appeal to wide audiences and composers went to great lengths to make it understandable for many people by doing things like including programs to explain the story of a piece of strictly instrumental music.
Classical music is not all lofty, highly thought, intelligent stuff. It does have layers of complexity that popular music has not yet made wide use of (tempo changes, dynamics, etc.) but it has also had a lot longer to develop.
As classical musicians we need to get away from the idea that only people intelligent people educated in classical music can listen to it. All this does is drives potential new listeners away and further harms our art form. If we become so elite that no one listens to it any more, that will be it.
Any one who denies that popular music is a legitimate art form (especially with how widely it is accepted not just in our country, but around the world) needs to seriously re-examine how they define the world art. Remember that music is anything that a society defines as music, or anything that intentionally breaks from that definition.
backwardsinheels
April 2, 2009 - 5:09 amPowered by Yahoo Answers
1. It’s supposed to be nerdy to like classical music and “cool” to dislike it. They don’t want to lose face.
2. People fear and hate what they don’t understand. No one ever sat down with this girl and showed her how lovely and powerful Classical Music is. It confuses her, so she shuts it out.
If you get the opportunity, ease her into classical by demonstrating the power of music in film.
Elaine C
April 5, 2009 - 11:37 amPowered by Yahoo Answers
That’s a very good question, and it’s generated a lot of good, thoughtful answers.
Here’s an idea that no one may have mentioned yet: there is a philosophical tendency these days to be suspicious of anything that looks too beautiful, too sincere, too good, too perfect, etc. Ugliness is in fashion, and nowhere is this more apparent than in popular music.
Ever notice how many people come here to ask for recommendations of works that are “dark, evil, satanic, hard, scary, grim”…. etc., etc.? Please don’t think I’m making fun of those seekers–I’m glad they’re here, glad they’re willing to explore a different genre. But doesn’t it tell you something, that so many people find their way here because they’re looking for loud, evil-sounding music?
We all know that there’s a lot of classical music like that. Shostakovich, Stravinsky, Prokofiev, Berlioz–we love you.
But a great deal of classical music (even the interior movements of those angst-ridden masterpieces) is shockingly, subversively, gloriously BEAUTIFUL. And Mozart and his classical-era cohorts hardly knew the meaning of the word “irony.”
I don’t think it’s elitist to say this: classical music is what it is. No, we don’t have to be snobbish about it, but neither do we have to apologize for it and try to fit it into modern-looking garb. Yes, you can find irony and ugliness in classical music, but there’s even more that’s neither ironic nor ugly. And unless one can learn to appreciate sheer, unadulterated beauty, one may find it hard to wholly embrace classical music… especially the perfectly crafted works of composers like Mozart.